Which Is Worse An ACL Or MCL Tear?

Which is worse an ACL or MCL tear? The limitations vary depending on which ligament was injured. However, while both cause a lot of discomfort, technically speaking, an ACL tear could be considered as worse, since it may require surgery to fully heal. On the other hand, a minor MCL tear can heal on its own.

What is the most painful knee injury?

Partial tears mean the tendon has pulled away from the kneecap, but is still attached. These don't usually require surgery, just rest and physical therapy. Complete tears are more painful and the patellar tendon completely separates from the kneecap.

What is the most serious ligament injury in the knee?

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is the most commonly injured knee ligament.

Did I tear my ACL or MCL?

It can be easy to confuse the two injuries, as both a torn ACL and a torn MCL exhibits similar symptoms, including: swelling, inflammation, extreme pain and possible bruising. The main difference between an ACL tear and an MCL tear is that an ACL tear will have a distinctive popping sound, while an MCL tear will not.

Is it OK to walk with a torn MCL?

If the MCL or ACL tears, the result is usually pain, swelling, stiffness, and instability. In most cases, the injured person can still walk with the torn knee ligament. But the movement will be severely limited, not to mention painful. Surgery may be the best route to a pain-free life, with amazing success rates.


Related guide for Which Is Worse An ACL Or MCL Tear?


Is ACL the worst knee injury?

The quick answer is that the ACL (Anterior Cruciate Ligament) is most likely to be considered the worst ligament in the knee to tear.


How painful is an ACL?

Moderate-to-severe pain is very common. Initially, the pain is sharp and then becomes more of an ache or throbbing sensation as the knee swells. Since the ACL is the major knee stabilizer, an injury to it will cause the knee to give out or buckle when a person tries to walk or change direction.


What is the most painful leg injury?

1. Broken Femur. The femur is considered the longest, largest and strongest bone in the human body. So, when a bone of this size and strength is literally snapped in two, the pain is not only immediately agonizing, but also prolonged over a long period of time.


What's the most painful injury possible?

Most Painful Injuries a Person Can Experience

  • Broken Femur. Broken bones almost always hurt.
  • Kidney Stones. Anyone who's had a kidney stone can testify to the fact that they've never experienced anything more painful in their life.
  • Shingles.
  • Third Degree Burns.
  • Slipped Disc.

  • Where does a MCL tear hurt?

    MCL injuries hurt. Most people feel pain along the inside edge of the knee, and they also have swelling. You might hear a pop when the damage to the knee takes place, and your knee may lurch to the side. You may find it hard to walk, or feel like you can't put pressure on the leg with the hurt knee.


    Is the MCL on the inside or outside?

    An MCL injury is a sprain or tear to the medial collateral ligament. The MCL is a band of tissue on the inside of your knee. It connects your thighbone to the bone of your lower leg. The MCL keeps the knee from bending inward.


    How long is ACL recovery?

    Within the first few weeks after surgery, you should strive to regain a range of motion equal to that of your opposite knee. Recovery generally takes about nine months. It may take eight to 12 months or more before athletes can return to their sports.


    Can you live without an ACL?

    Without an ACL, the knee is unlikely to support aggressive landing, cutting and pivoting. Living with a torn ACL may mean limiting participation in sports, work and activities that cause the knee to swell, give way or feel unstable. Risk of other injuries.


    Does torn MCL pop?

    Most people who tear their MCL feel pain and a "pop" in their knee when the injury happens. Their knee usually swells soon after the injury, most of the time around the inside part of the knee.


    What does a torn MCL or ACL feel like?

    If you feel a sudden pain under your knee cap or hear a loud popping sound, you most likely have torn your ACL. Pain is usually immediate and swelling occurs in the next few hours following the incident.


    Will my MCL ever heal?

    As previously noted, recovery times vary widely, but in general: A grade 1 (minor) MCL tear can take from a few days to a week and a half to heal enough for a return to normal activities, including sports. A grade 2 tear can take from two to four weeks to heal.


    Is MCL the same as meniscus?

    MCL stands for medial collateral ligament and is located on the inside of the knee. The MCL originates on the femur (thigh bone) and inserts on the tibia (large bone of the lower leg). The MCL splits slightly at the knee joint and some fibers also insert onto the medial meniscus (cushion inside the knee).


    Does a Grade 1 ACL tear need surgery?

    ACL tears are graded by severity and are called sprains (a sprain is a stretch or tear in a ligament). A grade 1 ACL sprain occurs when your ACL is overstretched, but not torn. If your knee is still stable, you likely have a grade 1 injury and may not need surgery. A grade 2 ACL sprain is a partial tear.


    What's the difference between ACL and MCL?

    Both support and stabilize the knee. ACL is the anterior cruciate ligament that keeps your shinbone from sliding forward. MCL is the medial collateral ligament that prevents your femur from sliding from side to side. A knee injury can damage either of these ligaments.


    Can ACL tear painless?

    An ACL injury can be relatively painless. Some people twist their knees, hear a 'pop' as the ligament tears, and get plenty of swelling – but little discomfort. So it's possible to rupture your ACL and not be doubled-up in agony. On the other hand, they can sometimes be very painful.


    Why is a torn ACL so bad?

    Like all ligaments, the ACL takes a very long time to heal. The reason is because ligaments are poorly vascularized. In other words, there aren't many blood vessels to provide nutrients for the ligaments, and without nutrients, tissue repair is not possible.


    Will a torn ACL stop hurting?

    The swelling may resolve and pain fade a bit, but when you try to return to your sport, the knee will feel weak, unstable, and painful, and swelling may return. When you try to get up from the injury, you may feel the knee buckle and have trouble bearing weight on the injured knee.


    How Long Does ACL take to heal without surgery?

    Non-surgical Treatment

    The time it takes to recover is approximately 3 months.


    What is a Grade 1 ACL tear?

    Grade 1 – This is the mildest form of an ACL tear. A person who has a grade 1 tear is still able to walk and maintain some stability from the knee. While the ligament is stretched, it does not tear enough not to provide some function. Grade 2 – This is usually referred to as a partial tear.


    Is there bruising with ACL tear?

    Injury causing an ACL tear can also lead to a deep bone bruise. A bone bruise occurs when the ligament tears and the bones shift on one another. While bone bruising is a common characteristic of an ACL tear, it typically requires no treatment. Your body will heal the bruising on its own.


    What is the number one pain in the world?

    1. Cluster headaches. Cluster headaches are seriously debilitating bursts of pain in one side of the head, often felt near the eyes.


    What's the worst pain in the world physically?

    The full list, in no particular order, is as follows:

  • Shingles.
  • Cluster headaches.
  • Frozen shoulder.
  • Broken bones.
  • Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS)
  • Heart attack.
  • Slipped disc.
  • Sickle cell disease.

  • What's the first most painful thing a human can experience?

    In a new YouTube video, Justin Cottle at the Institute of Human Anatomy breaks down a condition that he has frequently heard people describe as the most painful thing they have ever experienced, with some even calling it more agonizing than childbirth: kidney stones.


    Was this post helpful?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published.